Phones answered Monday through Sunday, all dayDispatch: Paterson, NJ 07513

Home · 4 min read

Why Rekey Your Locks When Moving Into a New Home

Illustration for the article: Why Rekey Your Locks When Moving Into a New Home

You have no way of knowing how many copies of your new keys are still out there. Rekeying fixes that without replacing the hardware.

Who Else Has a Key to Your New Place?

When you move into a house or apartment, the keys you receive are rarely the only ones. Previous owners, past tenants, relatives, dog walkers, cleaners and contractors may all have been handed copies over the years, and few people keep track of them.

Rekeying changes the internal pins of a lock so the old keys stop working and a new set of keys takes over. It is one of the simplest ways to make sure that the only people who can open your door are the people you choose.

  • Former owners or tenants who kept a spare
  • Neighbors or friends who were given a key for emergencies
  • Real estate agents, inspectors and contractors who had access during the sale or turnover
  • Keys hidden under mats, in planters or in lockboxes and forgotten

How Rekeying Works

Most pin tumbler locks contain a set of small spring-loaded pins of different lengths. A key works when its cuts lift those pins to exactly the right height. During a rekey, the locksmith removes the cylinder, takes out the old pins and installs a new combination that matches a freshly cut key.

The lock body, handle and deadbolt stay on the door. Only the inside of the cylinder changes, which is why rekeying is usually less expensive than buying and installing brand new locks. Many homeowners also ask to have every exterior lock rekeyed to the same key, so one key opens the front door, back door and side entry.

Rekeying vs. Changing the Locks

Rekeying makes sense when your existing locks are in good working order and you are happy with how they look and perform. A full lock change is the better choice when the hardware is worn, damaged, low quality or simply not the style you want.

Moving is also a good moment to look at the whole door. If the front entry has only a knob lock, adding a solid deadbolt is worth considering at the same time.

  • Choose rekeying if locks work smoothly and you just need new keys
  • Choose replacement if locks stick, wobble, look worn or are damaged
  • Consider an upgrade if you want a deadbolt, smart lock or keyless entry

Notes for Renters

Renters have a real interest in knowing who can get in, but the rules about changing or rekeying a rental's locks vary. Some leases require written permission first, some require that the landlord receive a copy of the new key, and practices differ from building to building.

Before you call anyone, read your lease and talk to your landlord or property manager. Ask whether the locks were rekeyed after the last tenant left. If they were not, many landlords are willing to arrange it or to allow you to do it at your own cost. Check your lease and local rules rather than assuming either way. If you are ever locked out of a rental, our apartment lockout tips cover the landlord side too.

Making It Part of Your Moving Checklist

The easiest time to rekey is soon after you get the keys, before boxes and furniture take over your schedule. Count every exterior door, including garage entry doors, basement doors and any mailbox lock, so the locksmith can plan the job in one visit.

Paterson Locksmith & Key can arrange for a local locksmith to come to your new address and handle the rekey. You get a price before work begins, and you can check our current coupons, which include a move-in special and a rekey offer where the fifth lock is free when you rekey four.

Frequently asked questions

Is rekeying as secure as buying new locks?

Rekeying makes old keys useless, which handles the main concern after a move. It does not upgrade the lock itself, so if the hardware is weak or worn, replacing it may be the better option.

Can all my doors use one key after rekeying?

Often yes, if the locks share the same keyway or brand. The locksmith can tell you once they look at your hardware, and in some cases a cylinder may need to be swapped to make it work.

As a renter, can I rekey without asking my landlord?

It depends on your lease and local rules. Many leases require permission and a copy of the new key, so check with your landlord or property manager first.

Locked out, lost a key or need stronger locks?

Call now and a dispatcher will explain the price and arrange a local locksmith.

Call 973-864-3148 Text